Translate

Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts

Friday, May 16, 2014

Right to be Forgotten: Opinion

I'm sure I don't need to remind everyone on the EU's ruling over the Google-Gonzalez case. Basically put for those of you still unaware, a Spanish man (Mario Costeja Gonzalez) discovered a search result on Google over a decade old, showing his old house up for auction in order to pay his debts. As I'm sure you can understand, such a result can pose certain financial difficulties in securing finance for the future. This, he argued in the European Court, is in violation of a 'right to be forgotten' (a right that has been sought by others before him up to two years ago) and Google should respond to his request that the unwanted search result be delisted (see the BBC Article.)

Surprisingly, the EU Court ruled in favour of the man and forced the California-based search giant to honour such requests in the future. Naturally this has caused an explosion of opinion and has rekindled the fires of mistrust over who collects our data. The ruling is unprecedented, with Wikipedia co-founder Jimmy Wales calling it one of the most "...wide-sweeping Internet censorship rulings I've ever seen..." He doesn't believe that it will stand for very long and already there have been protests against the EU Court's decision over the implications that such a ruling will have.

Against the Ruling:

The concern over this ruling by freedom-supporters is that "outdated and irrelevant results" is far too broad a ruling. The obvious implications over this is that near-enough anyone could go to Google and claim a critical article of them -however factual or valid- is "irrelevant" and "outdated." For example, last year I wrote a critical article about Secretary of State for Work & Pensions Iain Duncan Smith, accusing him of wasting money on politically-motivated projects based on bigoted opinions. Using this ruling, he could claim that my article is irrelevant and outdated and -by going to Google- could request that the article be removed from search indexes. You can see how this is ultimately insidious, because it is not active censorship in the sense of articles being taken off the web completely, but rather only gatekeepers of the web i.e. search engines who drive the traffic, will be prevented from doing that, which means that the article I wrote will be lost to the thickening forests of data increasingly being indexed by Google daily. This will lead to my article ultimately becoming lost on those who should be reading it and thus, our hypothetical goal for IDS will be complete: Censorship of criticism.

As a small aside, Google have since received 'forget me' requests, including those from a disgraced politician and a paedophile, which serve to highlight the original concerns.

In Favour of the Ruling:

Those who support the ruling are primarily those pushing for greater ability to manage their individual data. This will include those for example who don't wish to see a prospective employer pulling up their data as an excuse to fire them. YouGov have commissioned a poll since, which shows British public support for the ruling (50% Yes; 23% No.) However, it should be noted that the vast majority of these people do not see any personal need to pursue such requests (73% said there wasn't any irrelevant etc. data online, only 9% said yes.)

As I am sure most of you will know, companies these days will refer to Google for information about prospective employees, primarily trawling through social media profiles. We were given a lecture last year on this subject and below are two images from the presentation showing statistics for rejection/hiring, based on results from social media searches (Goldstraw, 2013):


Why they were Rejected


Why they were Hired

These charts show that a great many people are not even invited for an interview because their social media profiles are filled with images of irresponsible behaviour, posts of an unsavoury character or just lies lies and more lies. This ruling will be able to inhibit such processes but -as was pointed out in  the original BBC article, it will do little to stop a determined party from accessing such data anyway.

So What is My Opinion?

While I dislike those who try to censor the world around them and can't stand it when politicians/courts try to meddle with others' affairs, I find it hard to be truly outraged at this ruling, a little annoyed, but not much beyond that. The main reason for this is quite simply that, firstly, Google's mission statement is to make the world's information accessible and available to whomever wishes to see it, which of course can't be done with this ruling in place. Google's team of lawyers I'm sure will fight tooth and nail over this ruling and will ensure that it remains difficult for such requests to be passed. Why is this? Because -quite simply- Google make money through advertising services placed on websites, adjacent to content etc., which will be inhibited if their search indexes are shrunk by this ruling, due to so many de-listings of search results from disgruntled parties. This will mean -naturally- that as few requests as possible are acknowledged in order to retain large profitability.

Now providing that my prediction is correct, this could engender a two-tier system of requests. Imagine two different people who wish to see "irrelevant" and "outdated" content removed from the web: The first is an average man who posted something unsavoury on Facebook and wants it removed, while another is a powerful celebrity wishing to see a magazine article taken down because it defames their character (assume that the article is not untrue but rather shows the celeb in question in an unflattering light, but as a result of their own reckless behaviour nevertheless.) It is natural to assume that the celebrity -who may threaten with lawsuit- is more likely to have a request passed than the average person, of whom there will infinitely more and will deliver a larger loss for Google collectively. They are currently implementing a request button of some kind that will be ready in a matter of weeks. From here one can only imagine what the process will be like, however, the interesting thing is that Google can counter requests, but only if the person in question is a public figure, which suggests that anyone else is immune to scrutiny from Google.

Given all of these facts, I personally have to stand against this decision on Google, because I ultimately place the right to know higher than the right to be forgotten. People should have a right to know if it will concern them in some way e.g. an employer wishing to check a person's background, because this can be costly to businesses who may hire what turns out to be the wrong person. While I respect privacy, sometimes it is a price worth paying I believe for a universal standard that covers everyone regards to the data they choose to put online etc. We already have defamation and libel laws that adequately cover falsehoods posted by others after all, so why the extra ruling I ask? 

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

Carat Media Internship: Journal Entry #23

Admittedly this post is slightly late as I've been rather busy recently. Last week was very enjoyable albeit a little similar to the week before. I was involved with our DSPs using pixels again, but this time I only looked for the age of the average converting customer as opposed to examining more than one market. Apparently the digital executives manning the Irish desk were quite pleased last week I'm glad to report, so I guess I did right after all, despite my initial doubts. After completing around 9 different campaigns spread across three of our clients I moved onto a new task, using an online maps tool to discover postcode radii.

Pixels

I used the radius tool to focus on London and proceeded to select a radius of around 30Km I think. From here I examined the numbers appearing against the areas, showing population size, which I then cross-referenced with official statistics to discern the areas outside of London with the highest populations. These areas were then placed onto a simple list in Excel and sent off to my colleague, who used the list to select towns and cities from within another DSP. This was again an interesting experience, which taught me a little about the most populated areas of the country and their history as I browsed government reports and Wikipedia, making the task a rather fun one to complete.

My final task for the day was to complete another site list removal, examining campaigns for three more clients. Here I removed the obvious sites, those with unusual URLs, dead links, irrelevant pages and again, these were placed into a removal list within our DSP, which should hopefully funnel out options for targeting sites with our ads. After all, the more bad sites we remove, the less of them there will be and easier it will become to engage our audience.

Thanks for reading this post and I think that this week will be my last session on the internship, which is sad to say the least. The exams are beginning to loom and the year will come to a close in time. So I am afraid to say that the next post on this internship will be my last and before I go I will say that it has been a massive experience for me. Before arriving at Carat I had next to no knowledge of so much, whether that be Excel, digital analytics, databases etc. and after working here for some six months I can definitely say that, even though I am sure I have only scratched the surface, it feels like I've gained an entire repository of knowledge. It's been great fun and so we charge ahead into the final week, next week . . .

Friday, November 15, 2013

Carat Media Internship: Journal Entry #5

A couple of weeks ago I carried out some very interesting tasks on MediaMath and Double Click (the ad platforms.) I pulled the reports on the clients myself this time, the interfaces of both platforms being so easy to use and are quite intuitive, I found. All you have to do on MediaMath for example, is basically select your client and then the report type that you want to build (in my case, a keyword report, and then later a site transparency one,) and from here, you'll be prompted to select from a range of criteria to measure (such as CPC, CTR, CPA, CPM, Clicks/Impressions etc.) or alternatively, you can choose all the data available and export it as a simple (but often data-intense!) spreadsheet. When you've got the spreadsheet, you can then go and do what needs to be done with the data contained within.

As for Double Click, once you arrive at the main page, you simply select the "New Report" option and fill in the details i.e. client, report type etc. From here, Google will build a report featuring the data that you wanted to see and then you'll do the same as above. As you can probably see below, there's a very similar layout to both sites and both are very easy to use once you've gotten to grips with them, no different than the Facebook Ad Manager platform I used a couple of weeks ago and again this week.

I learnt a great deal from the analytics conducted, namely the difference between post-view conversions and post-click conversions; as the names imply, the former occurs only when a consumer sees an ad but does not click on it, but nevertheless, they then proceed to visit the page organically, thereby saving the company money and giving them a conversion at the same time; though that would also mean that content creators with the ad placed on their site would see a reduction in the amount they receive because, despite being part of the purchase path taken, they were not the sole way in which the customer was advertised to by Google etc. and the consumer did not click the ad; as a result, they would not receive the full amount for such an action. The latter conversion type is the bog-standard click the ad, pay for it, and then managed to get a conversion out of it as well, but at a cost to the client.

Without dwelling too much on the same tasks and becoming tiresome for you, I also completed another Facebook Ad Spreadsheet, but this time I decided to do something else that I wasn't asked for (largely out of wanting to spend the last twenty minutes or so productively.) When looking at the clicks for out client (their campaign had just come to an end on that particular day,) I separated the clicks into "social clicks" (a metric found within the data) and the normal clicks by using a calculator to take away the social clicks from the overall click total, thereby disclosing what amount of the clicks came from non-social platforms. I then placed this data into a simple pie chart, depicting the data as a percentage. Here are the results!


As you can see, most of our clicks came from outside of social platforms, so maybe out client's customers don't like being pestered when talking to friends! Not that you can really draw a conclusion from this data alone, but it does provide an interesting dynamic to look at don't you think?

Aside from the tasks, the work and the clients, I've also enjoyed the chit-chat over the last month that I've been here. It certainly livens up the atmosphere of the office that would probably be dull and lifeless without it. Finding things in common with people, talking about out lives, experiences, hobbies and anything else we can muster really places a nice slant on the experience of working, and just makes the hours go flying by without a clock fast enough to measure them! And until we meet again next week, I bid you a good day and hope that you can tune in again for the next chapter of my story, a romance about a marketing agency, because one can indeed love maths and analysis, (and this comes from someone who loathed the subject at school.) But in all seriousness, see you soon and have a good day . . .

Thursday, October 31, 2013

Carat Media Internship: Journal Entry #3

* Please note that this was written a couple of weeks ago because it needed managerial approval before i could be posted. Thanks!

Last week proved rather eventful at work. I completed some more tasks for our clients through Facebook, made recommendations and wrote a lot of it down. But this week I moved onto something else! The new task still revolved around using Excel but instead of Facebook, I used Google's Display Network (GDN) to find the info.

Unfortunately I haven't yet used the actual platform but instead manipulated the data to discern some useful information. I used the Filter option within the spreadsheet to select certain data that fell within a certain range e.g. CPCs at £0.25+ only. This was usually in conjunction with another function such as selecting the column for CTRs and setting the filter to have the values in descending order from the highest. When used together, those two functions should leave the top of the table filled with the data ranges containing the highest CTRs only with 25p CPC or more. Combining several filters is how you can really drill right down into the most significant factors and when you discover bad/good data, you can highlight it appropriately.

However, once discovering the data needed, I wrote explanations for why the data was how it was, analysing the source of the traffic and -when looking into the Google Keywords spreadsheet- evaluating the most effective websites in addition to discussing not only the keyword used, but also the Ad Group into which it fell i.e. a keyword of "things to do 2013" would fall into the Ad Group of "things to do," with possibly several options added for as many keywords as were deemed necessary when the campaign was initially set up.

As the weeks go by I find myself going through the Excel sheets with greater speed as the processes become memorised and I jump from place to place, setting the controls appropriately as I go. Not only that, but I find that my analytical skills are improving and as I become more confident with Excel, I try to do things to the sheet that aren't on the list e.g. re-setting the filters in yesterday's case to try and prove a hypothesis about the data that I had, organising the filter through the keyword and Ad Group to see the frequency of failure in a specific campaign that I had doubts of.


 My Professional Development Assignment for the university; I need to prove that I've developed some sound skills and competencies, as well as a mature approach to work behaviour and a good attitude to the job/field.













Sorry if this post is a little short/sparse on info, I didn't want to fall into the trap of repeating myself week in week out and boring you to death! Not only that but yesterday I had to take a slightly longer lunch break because of a university meeting that unfortunately clashed with the work hours. But I did stay a little longer than usual though so I suppose I made up for it!

Week 2
Week 4

Saturday, October 12, 2013

The Nescafe Facebook Page: A Content Review

In a spur of the moment decision, I've decided to put my thoughts out there on a Facebook page that I absolutely love. The Nescafe page with upwards of 12 million Likes.

In recent years as social media has taken off, companies have tried tirelessly to create engaging social pages that humanise their brands and products as much as possible. After all, brands aren't just products anymore, but lifestyles; a symbiosis of life between us just bubbling away at the surface of society and seeping through to its very roots, sitting all around us every day, wanting to tell us their story, their origins; (our friends at Carat published a similar blog post a while ago on the subject of 'Brand Narratives' and I would recommend that you check that out.) To many this is a permissible phenomenon whilst others have voiced disapproval. I reviewed the book No Logo by Naomi Klein some time ago now, just in case you want more on that particular perspective. But this is merely the background as to why companies try to be as innovative as they can, to attract the most social commerce.

And it is that point that leads me to this review of Nescafe. Why do I like it? Well, aside from being a routine buyer of their coffee, I've kept them in my timeline because of a few salient reasons: Firstly, they publish content regularly, unlike some other coffee companies such as Costa Coffee, who I also liked through Facebook (yes I'm a coffee addict!) This is crucial for any business trying to establish a firm base on a social media outlet, you need to keep it updated; it's like a blog, a tracker of your life and if it's neglected or under-updated overtime, consumers will begin to lose interest.

But with the baby steps of having the basic commitment out of the way, we can get down to the nitty gritty: Why is their content so special? Well that's for multiple reasons: The main one is that it's just plain funny, constantly playing upon people's general tiredness and need for constant energy, or more often just uploading cool pics with innovative ideas! Look at some of these recent images.




 
I'm Glad Monday's My Day Off This Year!




















Smile!



They also recently uploaded a series of images forming a recipe for a Nescafe Milkshake! Like I said, the content is innovative, it's fairly original and it's a brilliant addition to their communication strategy. But the best thing about this or any other Facebook page is that -largely- it's free to do! Of course there was probably a great deal of cash that went into producing those images; the equipment, the staff etc. but even when that is considered, it's so much cheaper than filming an advert and spending vast sums on a national campaign. But in a final note, to revert back to the Carat article in particular, they have used the Facebook timeline -like many other companies- to detail their history in the world, their origins, their landmark coffees and their participation in key world events, (I didn't know they'd been on the moon!) and it is that common feature that so many brand pages share. They want to tell us their story, and the Story of Nescafe is one that I thoroughly enjoyed!

The only real criticism that I have of Nescafe's Facebook page is that they focus a little too much I feel on their Original blend or their general brand. Looking at the content produced, I feel it would be fairly easy to incorporate their other blends into something artistic that could raise awareness of their other coffees and product lines. An interesting dynamic can be seen between both the Nescafe page and their Nespresso page, both tackling different arms of Nestle's coffee ventures.

But in all, I find the Nescafe page a particularly good example of a brand making good use of a social platform to spread it's message, and it is for that reason that I thought I should share it!

Please, feed back to me about this. Do you have any Facebook pages of brands that you enjoy, whose content you like? Let me know, I'd love to hear about them!