Translate

Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 20, 2014

UKIP: A Political Polemic

I thought I should weigh in on a political opinion of mine as the European and Local Elections loom closer. This post is not to discuss my own personal preference, vis-a-vis party affiliation, but rather it is here to address a gripe I have with a certain party. The United kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) is a Eurosceptic party that has been in existence since 1993. In recent years it has seen a surge in support amongst disaffected voters, amid concerns surrounding EU powers, British sovereignty and immigration in particular. As a result of this, five years ago, it became the second-largest British party in the European Parliament, second only to the Conservatives. A great deal has changed of course since 2009, but still some issues remain and UKIP has pledged to solve them in methods -they reassure us- that are common-sense and bold; in other words, they are the new party of the common man, unafraid to question the establishment. Nigel Farage, UKIP leader and current face of 'anti-politics' in Britain, has managed to gain a reputation as a down-to-earth chap you could even have a drink in a pub with. This post seeks to challenge this conception and I hope that you find this piece informative.

The entire raison d'être of UKIP is the EU and its many treaties that have transformed the body over the years. David Cameron -many have suspected in fearful response- has 'promised' a referendum on EU membership to extinguish the fires of political rebellion emanating from within his own party. True, Britain hasn't seen a referendum of this kind since Harold Wilson's referendum of 1975. Since then, treaties such as Maastricht (1992) and Lisbon (2007) have enshrined new powers of the EU and its members, the number of which has also grown since the initiation of our membership in 1973. Maastricht, for example, unified the European Economic Community and rallied their support for a single currency (the Euro) in addition to unifying us politically, in order to allow cross-state foreign policy decision-making and inter-continental policing; the union was both economic and monetary. Lisbon later formed, what is now called officially the European Union, replacing the European Community and striving for greater cohesion, such as that stated in Article 3, Point 2: "...free movement of persons... ensured in conjunction with appropriate measures with respect to external border controls, asylum, immigration and the prevention and combating of crime." 


This of course may seem dubious to some, who -like UKIP- believe that we no longer have control of our borders, yet another article can be referred to (Article 4 Point 2,) which stresses "...respect for members states... national identities, inherent in their fundamental structures, political and constitutional, inclusive of regional and local self-government." The point further states that self-government on these key issues is their concern when matters of national security and law and order are at stake, which of course refutes the notion that we cannot extradite terrorists on the grounds of Human Right laws (as Richard Littlejohn believes.) 


But of course UKIP is not just the single-issue party of EU membership, but rather a party of multiple policies. Recently, a Green Councillor by the name of Michael Abberton posted a leaflet onto his Twitter account, using UKIP logos and colour schemes listing "10 Reasons to Vote for UKIP."




This list (which has seen an updated versions with sources since published,) was investigated by the Cambridgeshire Police on the grounds of it violating the Representation of the People Act, specifically the article concerning the slanderous use of falsehoods to deliberately affect the outcome of an upcoming election; the UKIP affiliate in question who filed the original police complaint is still unknown. But for a party who claim to be pro-freedom to go to the police to solve this issue without first consulting the man who posted it, speaks volumes of their hypocrisy. And without further delay, let's look into this supposed Green propaganda.

1) Scrapping Paid Maternity Leave


This policy was posted onto the affiliate website of a man named Amjad Bashir, the small and medium business spokesperson and was essentially advertised under a list of EU regulations, followed by the tagline "Government is the problem, not the solution." Interestingly enough, the website has since had this deleted for obvious PR reasons. But thankfully, there is a YT video (I definitely recommend that you watch him,) featuring a screenshot of this website between the 5th and 6th of May, and you can clearly see that this was Bashir's policy until very recently. The images are below:



As the Website Stands Today

Until Recently

When perusing the web, I've seen some people defending UKIP and Bashir by saying that it wasn't in their manifesto (because no party really has one at present for the 2015 general election,) or alternatively, I've been hearing the argument advanced that this man is only an affiliate/not representative of UKIP. Really? Well please tell me then, why would a SME spokesman for UKIP (the man who would probably be Business Secretary if they ever got into power,) put something like this onto his website that runs as a UKIP promoter if it is not "part of UKIP policy"? If Ed Davey as Energy Secretary put onto his personal, Lib-Dem blog, that he wanted to scrap climate change policy (another UKIP policy by the way,) then that becomes not just a preference of a man in charge, but official policy of the body he is representing i.e. the Lib-Dems and the Coalition government, making it Tory policy too at that point.     

2-4) Raising income Tax for the Poorest 88% of Britons; Scrapping Holiday Entitlements & Speeding Up Privatisation of The NHS

These policies were quoted on the website of UKIP Birmingham spokesperson Keith Rowe, but unfortunately for us, the policies hyperlink no longer takes you anywhere. This naturally presents some problems for us but, given that Amjad was quick to remove the contentious issues from his site, it seems only natural for Keith to do so as well. UKIP have spoken often of County Health Boards, designed to increase competition within the NHS because, and I quote from memory Paul Nuttal's Question Time appearance "I believe that competition improves service [within the NHS]." For those of you wishing to see a more concrete example of this, I was lucky enough to find a screenshot from Nuttal's UKIP website.

UKIP Pro-Privatisation Letter

Scrapping Holiday Entitlements feed into the policies surrounding the EU Directives on work conditions, which is EU policy under what is known as the EU Working Time Directive. This states that individuals employed on a full-time basis are entitled to "4 weeks of paid annual leave." Given that UKIP wish to get rid of this policy, it seems only logical that they will do so via resigning from the EU Employment Law, which is laid side-by-side with the current UK employment law by the London Chamber of Commerce, here.

5) Cancelling All Planned House-Building

This originated from the copy of the 2010 Election Manifesto, the only link to which I found here. Although there is debate as to whether or not this is still official policy, there are some points in this manifesto that ring true with this kind of policy, such as "encouraging demand, not just supply" or "incentivise the use of 800,000 empty homes," which does insinuate a policy driven by current housing stock rather than building more homes, which, according to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation is a priority if we wish to see people continuing to own rather than rent.

6) Abandoning All Action on Climate Change

This point is elucidated by a gentleman who no longer works for UKIP but used to be their official Science Advisor; a man called Lord Christopher Monckton. He claimed constantly that he was the SA to Margaret Thatcher, despite the fact that she didn't credit him with the position in her own autobiography. A YouTube user and climate scientist who runs the Potholer54 channel has rebuked many of Monckton's claims and misrepresentations of climate change and has even sent correspondence to him, so definitely check out those videos. The specific playlist linked has 5 videos titled "Monckton Bunkum Part 1-5." Essentially, Monckton constantly claimed that ice yield has reduced between -generally- a few years worth of time and has concluded from this microscopic datum that climate change is a myth. The Daily Mail (that bastion of integrity!) has made similar claims such as the infamous "Global Warming Stopped in 1997," based on a small MET Office update that said no such thing. If however you look into a longer graph -such as this one from the NCDC- it shows a very different trend indeed. Also, according to the National Snow & Ice Data Centre the ice yield for the years 1978-2010, showed a linear decrease in ice yield of 3.3% per decade. 

National Climatic Data Centre (a US Organisation)

National Snow & Ice Data Centre

7) Cancelling Regulation to Make Banks Safer

This is backed up thanks to Coughlan's earlier video to which I linked in point 1. The Independent published this "Open Letter to Alex Jones" from Farage himself, in which he attacks Gordon Brown for handing over regulations to "Canary Wharf" but wishes to remove more regulations -such as those imposed by the EU- on banking, which of course fits in rather well with their "free market solves all" mentality. Please note however that the only source for their deregulation claims as it stands is in the student-run, political-neutrality-claiming magazine: The Yorker.

8) Abolishing Your EU Human Rights

This is of course a long-standing UKIP policy, though here it could be argued that many of these principles in the EU Human Rights Act are already upheld in Common Law and Habeas Corpus. But considering what we already know about UKIP and their tendencies surrounding limiting worker freedoms, it does beg the question as to the motivation for abolishing this legislation. But the key point here is that -firstly- the European Court is not a body of the EU, but rather the Council of Europe and -secondly- the administration of these laws by the European Court in Strasbourg, is only possible once all other court options within the member state concerned have been exhausted. Often these cases are resolved in the UK, as seen our earlier example of terror suspect Abu Qatarda who was finally extradited to Jordan last year. His lengthy stay in this country however was perpetuated not thanks to the European Court, but rather a UK Court after having won his immigration appeal in the first place.

9) Making it Legal for a Man to Rape or Assault His Wife

The law only changed on marital rape in 1991 despite critiques as far back as the 19th century. Nevertheless, a UKIP backer recently said that "there is no such thing as marital rape," a comment that has obviously provoked outcry. This falls into line with a reported rebellion against the EU in 2006, on a motion titled "Combating Violence Against Women." Of the 14 MEPs who rebelled and voted against the movement, 8 were UKIP members.

10) Cutting Education Spending & Buying 3 Aircraft Carriers Instead

Now, this issue with UKIP can be traced back to their 2010 Manifesto, in which restoration processes for the military were on the table, including the specific purchase of light jets and aircraft carriers. The education policy is one advocating a return to the Grammar School system and the implementation of County Education Boards, akin to the ones that they wish to set up for the NHS; a franchised system, where charities and parent-run initiatives (such as current 'free schools' championed by Blair and continued by Gove,) would become the norm, alongside the perhaps more alarming "...not-for-profit and profit-making private companies..." This seems to suggest a similar libertarian approach to the schooling system and if indeed schools are franchised off to companies and charities, and combined with their low tax approach, it seems fairly logical that they will match the low taxes with a much lower spend, despite their desire to see increased military spending. This is followed by a policy of denationalising Further- and Higher-Education Institutions, instead replacing the loan/grant payment system with "Student Vouchers" and "Training Vouchers." These would be issued to everyone over the age of 18. The denationalised education establishments will be "...only accountable to their students" and "...run by charitable bodies."

And Finally . . . Number 11)

Phew! That took quite a while so if you've made it this far then I applaud you. But we aren't done yet, because there is a single point that I would like to address, a point reiterated continually by Farage that is just not true. The point is so crucial to the fear-mongering that they even went to the trouble of making a poster out of it:


Get Your Tin-Foil Hats on People, the Bureaucrats Are Coming!

Yes, that's right! Apparently 75% of our laws are made by the EU (and we all know the EU is a bunch of unelected, unrepresentative, crypto-fascist, do-gooding, PC-brigade, liberal-lefty, BBC wishy-washy bunch of commie wankers from Brussels right?) But sadly Farage has got it wrong again, because -firstly- to say that X amount of our laws are made the EU is a daft way to measure the impact as to our lives, because each individual law has a different impact than another might, which makes this so-called 'impact measurement' a fallacious one. But more importantly is the fact that the EU Parliament in which Farage sits (when he bothers to attend) is the body to which he is referring. Why else to we vote in European elections? To vote for our MEPs of course. According to the HoC Library (cited via FullFact) the claim of law % could be justified from anywhere between 15%-50%. This is because the laws are passed in different variations vis-a-vis EU/UK Parliament influence, the three categories being "Acts put in place by UK Parliament with EU Influence"; "Regulations Influenced by or Related to the EU" and finally "EU Regulations & Regulations Influenced by or Related to the EU." These different categories will of course contain different types/severities of laws, with the European Parliament voting for 70% of all laws passed (according to Vivianne Reding,) which is where UKIP distorted the claim, even after she said that she made a mistake in saying simply that the EU in general passes all these laws. Put simply, 70% of all laws passed within the EU are made by the elected MEPs of each member state. The other 30% are made by the European Council, made up by the Heads of State or Government of the member countries, meaning that David Cameron, as PM, is our current Council Representative. Of course this would challenge the idea of our Councillors etc. being unelected, but then again, Cameron wasn't really elected as PM was he, given the lack of a "Coalition" option on the ballot paper in 2010.

Thanks for reading! I'm glad that you took the time to read this and click on the links, and if you were thinking about voting for UKIP purely because of the EU, then I hope that this post made you think twice before voting for them. I could go into their more light-hearted controversies (Godfrey Bloom for example,) or perhaps show another weaselly excuse from Paul Nuttal about his attendance record being the worst; but I've realised that these things only serve to highlight the craziness, stupidity and -indeed- disingenuous nature of UKIP, and I didn't even have to resort to racism claims! And if you believe that this so-called "non-racist libertarian party" is a genuine one to vote for in order to show dissatisfaction with a body that, granted, isn't perfect, but far from unelected, then you might be better emigrating to Bongo-Bongo Land. But then again, you'd be an immigrant there wouldn't you?

Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Killing Two Birds with One Stone

Sorry I haven't updated this blog over the last month, but with exams approaching and placements to apply for I've been a little snowed under. This post will be very different and if you don't like Sociology then you probably won't like what follows. In an attempt to revise for an exam that I have at the end of the week, I am going to write an essay right here, on this page, in order to test my knowledge of consumption as understood by key theorists. Thanks for reading and I'll be writing a more conventional post on here soon (I think!)

Firstly, Marx saw consumption as a symptom of Capitalism that was often derived from the misery of those whose labour produced the product, or what he called Exploitation. This exploitation was allowed to go unpunished by the bourgeoisie who used marketing and subversive tactics in order to inject a type of magic into products that the consumer would identify with (as opposed to the workers,) a process he called Commodity Fetishism. This ultimately achieved the goal of the bourgeoisie, to Alienate the consumer from their fellow man and the problems others experience as well as Alienating the workers from their own work, so that, in essence, the workers' labour would be absorbed by the entity for whom they worked, in attempts to position the corporation (as one of Capitalism's flagship economic entities) as the superior party. This is ultimately related to Marx's binary class structure, based around conflict which -he believed- to the the story of human history, citing the revolutions of the past (e.g. French) as the endgame of the narrative in order to establish a new economic paradigm.

Emile Dirkheim (a Functionalist) on the other hand, found fault with Marx's interpretations of people's position in society, saying that people seek greater control and social integration via Social Solidarity, not less as was Marx's view. Functionalism states that society is akin to an anatomical structure, with every aspect (even crime) as a necessary part of the society. These functions will naturally demand different people and different jobs, which is where the different functions come into play e.g. Eduction, Politics. Most importantly, is that these functions are seldom affected in isolation and rather the effects of one function will affect many others e.g. Politics and Eduction in policy relations. Functionalism also states that we naturally converge into a Value Consensus, where our values (drivers towards our goals) are prevalent across all groups. This can differ however between sub-cultures, which Dirkheim recognised, and as a result, these renegade group (sundered from society) are cited by Drikheim as an example of Egoism. This is similar to but wildly different from Anomie, which is where society's Norms (social behaviour codes) break down (which is seen quite often in riots.) Both Marx and Dirkheim saw Capitalism as a part of the problem, only Dirkheim saw Anomie as something to be suppressed rather than eradicated as Marx saw Alienation.

Moving on to Max Weber, he saw society as being defined by individuals, as opposed to the previous two who said that society defined the individual. Weber's theory revolves around Rationalisation, a critique of the encroachment of science and technology to the point where everything is calculable. This -he believed- lead to a decline in religious influence, which he believed to be an ethics resource, and as a result, the world began to lose wonder and spectacle; a process he called Disenchantment. This concept of Rationalisation is applied to what was called the Iron Cage of Bureaucracy, where the human dimension of anything is ultimately removed as red tape stifles life as people know it. He believed materialism was dangerously replacing much of what was previously held sacred, but disagreed on class with Marx, which he saw a multi-faceted, as did Dirkheim.

Weber's ideas influenced two contemporary theories, applying his ideas to the modern corporation because given the time in which Weber was writing, much of the industries he criticised were state-owned e.g. the police. The first of these theories is McDonaldisation from Ritzer. This theory states that -with increasing globalisation- the harmful business practices of McDonalds restaurants such as acute calculability, Taylorisitc management styles, control of the process and standardisation/predicability of services, were becoming increasingly prevalent across the world in different industries. This similarly was seen as a disenchanter as people continue to predict and calculate everything e.g. weight loss, BMI etc. or see the same, standardised television schedule (which can be influenced by powerful media companies e.g. Sky affecting football kick-off times.)

This, in turn, influenced a similar theory named Disneyisation (NOT to be confused with 'Disneyfication') where the principals of Disney theme parks become dominant. Disneyisation is characterised by spectacle and Re-enchantment of the world, where everything is constantly high-key, which is contrary to reality of course. The key principles are Theming (e.g. Nando's; Chiquito's etc.,) Hybrid-Consumption (e.g. shopping centres,) Performative Labour (such as children's entertainers,) Licensing (toy companies etc.) and Merchandising (sport teams for example.) These holistic consumption activities are almost manufactured and standardised too, which is where the former and latter theories overlap. Control is also present, however the key point to remember about the two is that while McDonaldisation focuses on the process, Disneyisation is focused primarily on the experience. In essence one could argue that the former is cancelled out by the latter, with the two extremes prevalent depending on the industry type e.g. production or services.

Moving on, we now come to Pierre Bourdieu. He believed that class systems were still prevalent in society, but argued against the binary split of Marx. Instead, he believed that society was determined by those of a specific culture and upbringing, which is why (he argued) that there were far less working class children in higher education, because the language the classes used when amongst their own was restricted by those of a working class background and not within the higher classes. This of course was criticised as being too broad to generalise from but nevertheless, Bourdieu's three capital types are used to this day e.g. within the recent BBC class calculator. Middle class people he believed had a distinct advantage when it came to education, that their parents' Social Capital  allowed for confidence-building and networking with important people and Cultural Capital relates to the previous point in their traditional and more high-brow Taste (aesthetic judgement,) which was also a part of the educational culture. However, classes were not powerful in all areas he conceded, because someone who is knowledgable on literature for example, may have no knowledge (and therefore no Cultural Capital) on other subjects e.g. Science. This relates to the flagship idea of his theory, the concept of Social Fields. A social field is just a facet of society at large and could potentially be anything, any activity, any subject. This, he argued, is why we consume, because we are involved with different social fields and exhibit our own Taste in things as a result of our three capital types. However, he also argued the existence of sub-cultures or a Habitus, each possessing a certain mind-set or Doxa in which consumption may differ from most of society. Gangs are a common example of this, which is also where a phenomenon known as Symbolic Violence often arose, that is the belligerent display of a symbol to demonstrate power over others. This myriad consumption activities is a very broad theory that manages to remain fairly neutral vis-a-vis Capitalism.

Consumption is seen as liberating by some however, and these are the Post-Modernists. These people believe that consumption is what humans seek to participate in because it expresses individuality. The age of Modernism was characterised by everything being functional and large but generally was aesthetically unappealing e.g. modern towns such as Milton Keynes. PM was different in that things had to be functional, but also had to look the part, which is seen in most modern buildings featuring a range of hi-tech features such as eco technology and imposing skylines of clear glass or innovative architectural artistry, as seen in some hotels and modern offices e.g. Apple's Infinity Loop. A post-modern world also rejects many assumptions made by society, such as on gender. To a postmodernist gender is a spectrum and consumption activities/possibilities are endless. This is largely due to an erosion of space and time, with 24-hour news etc. that is constantly updated and is often intertextual, blending fiction and the real into what has been described as Hyper-reality. Naturally, the theory also rejects previous assumptions made about class systems and argues that in the age of the digital, classes are increasingly being fragmented and are becoming irrelevant. The two most important tenants of this theory are Spectacle/Symbolic Consumption and the Hyper-Reality/Intertextuality.

Thank you for reading this rather impromptu essay. I can't believe I actually remembered all of that without having to refresh my memory in the textbooks. In any case I hope you found it useful and if you've learnt something from it then great, I hope it serves you well in the future!

Thanks again

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Maxims of the Morons

This post is going to be a little different to the usual, as I dispel something that I just had to address. For those of you who know a little about (white) nationalism on the Internet, you may have come across complete retards posting stuff like 'anti-racist is codeword for anti-white' amongst other guff. It comes from a Canadian politician called Bob Whitaker who has written a document called Bob's Mantra. Here it is:

ASIA FOR THE ASIANS, AFRICA FOR THE AFRICANS, WHITE COUNTRIES FOR EVERYBODY!


Everybody says there is this RACE problem. Everybody says this RACE problem will be solved when the third world pours into EVERY white country and ONLY into white countries.
The Netherlands and Belgium are just as crowded as Japan or Taiwan, but nobody says Japan or Taiwan will solve this RACE problem by bringing in millions of third worlders and quote assimilating unquote with them.
Everybody says the final solution to this RACE problem is for EVERY white country and ONLY white countries to “assimilate,” i.e., intermarry, with all those non-whites.
What if I said there was this RACE problem and this RACE problem would be solved only if hundreds of millions of non-blacks were brought into EVERY black country and ONLY into black countries?
How long would it take anyone to realize I’m not talking about a RACE problem. I am talking about the final solution to the BLACK problem?
And how long would it take any sane black man to notice this and what kind of psycho black man wouldn’t object to this?
But if I tell that obvious truth about the ongoing program of genocide against my race, the white race, Liberals and respectable conservatives agree that I am a naziwhowantstokillsixmillionjews.
They say they are anti-racist. What they are is anti-white.
Anti-racist is a code word for anti-white

Now straight away we can see a huge error in the strapline alone, conflating continents with 'racial' criterion of countries. I'll revisit the error of 'white countries' in due time, but for the moment let's press on to the start of the mantra.
"Everybody says there is a RACE problem." Who says; everybody apparently, apart of course from all of those people who don't, myself included. "Everybody says this RACE problem will be solved when the third world pours into EVERY white country and ONLY white countries." Here's a newsflash: Countries are not defined by the colour of the skin of the majority of the inhabitants who happen to live there; ONLY by racists have they ever been defined in such a way.
Moving on, Whitaker makes the claim that Japan and the Netherlands are just as crowded as Belgium and Taiwan. Okay then, here are some figures for population density per Sq mile, which is not the measurement for how 'crowded' a country is because as we all know, much of Japan is inhospitable i.e. everybody lives on one piece of the land instead of there being complete human spread across a typical Sq Mile land mass. Here are the figures:
Japan: 873 People per Sq Mile
Belgium: 879 People per Sq Mile
Netherlands: 1023 People per Sq Mile
Taiwan: 1849 People per Sq Mile 
Okay, so he's part right about that at least but to put this into perspective, here are some other countries with a higher population density than Japan: Monaco- 42143 People per Sq Mile; Singapore- 18645 People per Sq Mile and finally Gibraltar- 12056 People per Sq Mile. So is Monaco more crowded than Japan, of course not, because the infrastructure of the country and what occupies the land mass takes up more space than the humans who live there. 

Progressing to the next paragraph, Whitaker ominously suggests that the "final solution" to the so-called race problem is only white countries assimilating or intermarrying with other races. This of course is bollocks because there are NO 'black' OR 'white' countries; it's as if he thinks whites never go anywhere else despite the fact that America was founded upon mass immigration by largely whites from Europe, as was S. Africa and Australia. 

More to the point, there is absolutely nobody FORCING whites to intermarry and/or have kids with anyone that they don't wish to. His further hypothetical of the situation, turning on it's head and the shoe being on the other foot with so-called 'black' countries accepting mass white immigration, he brands this as people perceiving the "'final solution' to the BLACK problem," which is where he begins to suggest that a genocide against the whites is sliding by unchallenged, alleging that any "sane" black man would object to this.

He then accuses Liberals and respectable Conservatives (obviously he isn't respectable,) of branding him a "naziwhowantstokillsixmillionjews" and states that the anti-racists are anti-white. This is the utter logic fail that brings this mantra to its knees, since anti-racist is code for anti-white, which pretty much states that whites are either inherently racist or implies that all whites should be racist, because white would equal racist according to this logic. 

The funny thing about this is that these so-called white nationalists, also white supremacists as well, more often than not, taking pride etc. in their ethnicity; yet by saying that whites are going to be wiped out out of existence via breeding, what they are effectively saying is that black genes are more dominant than white genes, which would usually lend credence to those espousing 'scientifically racist' views on the nature of races and their alleged superiority/inferiority dressed up as 'recognising differences'. Ironically, these are the true black supremacists because they believe that white genes are somehow wiped out, though in reality any set of black/white parents could theoretically have one child entirely black and another entirely white, because the genes from both parents are present regardless.

But the final point is on the idea of the white genocide. These people often claim that their definition of the word genocide comes from the United Nations Convention on Genocide, specifically Articles 2 & 3. Here they are:


Article 2


In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: (my underline)

  • (a) Killing members of the group;
  • (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
  • (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
  • (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
  • (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.


Article 3


The following acts shall be punishable:

  • (a) Genocide;
  • (b) Conspiracy to commit genocide;
  • (c) Direct and public incitement to commit genocide;
  • (d) Attempt to commit genocide;
  • (e) Complicity in genocide.

Okay then, so let's go through Article 2.

a) No one is being killed; in fact the argument Whitaker uses is that more people are being produced.
b) Serious bodily or mental harm is not happening aside from the mental anguish caused to a few bigots it seems. The rest of us seem just fine in living with those who are ethnically different.
c) Nothing is being CALCULATED; there is no such thing, according to the UN, as an indirect genocide. 
d) No births are being prevented; if anything, the argument is once against about births happening albeit being outside the preferred skin colour of Whitaker and co.
e) No children are being forced, against their will to transfer or are being exiled. Again, if anything the argument being used is about more children being created in countries that Whitaker deems to be 'white' areas.

So in summary NONE of this applies to the narrative of the white genocide conspiracy theorist, the arguments generally describing anything but a genocide. And also, here are some other questions:

WHO is doing it, considering most people in power in these areas of the world tend to be white?
WHY are they doing it, because those in power really don't benefit in any way from a whole segment of the population disappearing, especially given the fact that, again, those in power are white themselves. 
HOW do you get around the paradox of the anti- equivalences and the logical problems that they entail?

As a final message to the White Genocide morons, you can type that mantra into a comment section till time ends and it will convince no-one. The very definition of the word mantra is a slogan or song, tagline etc. It is NOT an argument for anything, the only use it has is as such, a song, a mantra to egg on those already pious, to preach to the already converted. 

Thanks for reading this critique and see you soon.

LINKS:

http://www.whitakeronline.org/blog/the-white-mantra/ (Bob's retarded 'Mantra' 15/9/2013)
http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0934666.html (Links to Population Densities, 15/9/2013)
http://www.hrweb.org/legal/genocide.html (UN Genocide Convention in full, 15/9/2013)

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Marketing: Book Recommendations (Scholastic Purposes)

BASICS:

Brassington, F. & Pettitt, S. (2006) Principles of Marketing
Jobber, D. (2010) Principles & Practice of Marketing
Baines, P., Fill, C. & Page, K. (2010) Marketing 
Yeshin, T. (2005) Advertising
Chaffey, D. & Smith P. R. (2008) eMarketing eXcellence (very good for digital basics combined with more traditional models; also goods for more practical purposes and not just academic)
Blythe, J. (2009) Principles & Practice of Marketing 

ETHICS & PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT:

Cottrell, S. (2008) Study Skills Handbook
Cottrell, S. (2010) Skills for Success
Chryssides, G. & Kaler J. (1996) Essentials of Business Ethics
Klein, N. (2000) No Logo
Bakan, J. (2005) The Corporation: The Pathological Pursuit of Profit & Power 
Rampton, S. & Stauber, J. (1995) Toxic Sludge is Good for You (mainly focuses on PR rather than marketing but a good read nevertheless)

COMMUNICATION THEORY:

Kitchen, P. J. (1999) Marketing Communications: Principles & Practices
Windahl, S., Signitzer, B & Olsen, J. T. (2008) Using Communication Theory: An Introduction to Planned Communication
Fill, C. (2006) Marketing Communication: Engagement, Strategies & Practice
Pickton, D. & Broderick, A. (2004) Integrated Marketing Communications

DIGITAL SOURCES & JOURNALS:

For news and more quickly-updated sources, the following hyperlinks will provide access to some very good journals and trade press

Marketing Magazine (UK) http://www.marketingmagazine.co.uk
PR Week http://www.prweek.com/uk/
The Grocer http://www.thegrocer.co.uk
Design Week http://www.designweek.co.uk
Chartered institute of Marketing (CIM) http://www.cim.co.uk/Home.aspx
Mashable http://mashable.com (especially good for social media research)
eConsultancy http://econsultancy.com/uk
Advertising Age http://adage.com
Forrester Research http://www.forrester.com/home/ (good for digital)

*The best database for journals is -in my opinion- Emerald; this will be invaluable if you have an institutional subscription e.g. from a university etc. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/index.htm?PHPSESSID=grl7dhksdql83oq54o52egv207

Sunday, August 4, 2013

Marketing Ethics: Essay on Mars & HM's Government Responsibility Deal


The essay below was written as an assignment for university, receiving a high score upon marking. I hope that you enjoy it and find it enlightening, although please bear in mind that the topic may be outdated by a couple of months at this point, being handed in in April this year. 
The assignment was split into four parts wherein we had to firstly state what the responsibility deal was and provide facts on the problem it attempted to solve, along with Mars' official response to it. Secondly, we had to discuss the for and against arguments with regards to Mars' position. Proceeding from this point, the discussion focused on highlighting the ethical arguments of Mars' critics, distilling their theoretical essence and then providing a critique of the government on its policy. Finally, two positions had to be adopted in the conclusion: A personal ethical summary of Mars and the government, with reasoned suggestions for increasing social good and secondly, the position of the marketing manager for Mars, and what could be done in that capacity to overcome the problems faced, both morally and practically.
The word count for this piece (excluding references/bibliography) was a maximum of 2000, hence the lack of great depth, so I hope it isn't too brief. I did change some of the language to make the piece flow a little better so the word count has increased slightly. Please feed back if you wish and thanks for reading.

 ABBREVIATIONS:

WHO: World Health Organisation
DfH: Department of Health
NHS: National Health Service
CMO: Chief Marketing Officer
CSR: Corporate Social Responsibility


INTRODUCTION:

The UK government’s Public Health Responsibility Deal is a pledge compiled by the current Department of Health to tackle ongoing concerns such as obesity, amongst other ailments (DfH, 2012a: Online.) The webpage detailing the partners (DfH, 2012b: Online,) cites several pledges from manufactures, distributors and suppliers of not just food and drink, but energy, insurance etc. This action is designed to empower companies to aid the nation in tackling its pervasive health problems. Concerns surrounding obesity include childhood obesity levels expected to reach 50% by 2020, (Wright, 2012a,) and general obesity rising above 20% for both genders (DfH, 2012c: Online.)

Mars has decided to launch five new Dolmio sauces that contribute to the nation’s recommended ‘5 a day’ (Reynolds, 2012,) as well as reducing the size of confectionary goods, such as the flagship Mars Bar and reducing the salt content of other food ranges (Mars Foods UK, 2012: Online.) Mars possesses an extensive brand and product portfolio including: Snickers, Galaxy, M&Ms and Milky Way (Mars Global, 2012: Online) and from this product range, there is a large portion of needless calories etc. that can be cut from the nation’s diet over the years, which should greatly aid the resistance to the obesity ‘epidemic’. Nevertheless, the policy set out by the current government has come under criticism alongside the food industry's participation.

MARS’ ETHICAL POSITION; FOR & AGAINST:

Mars’ position on this issue is to commit its expertise and resources to removing unnecessary numbers of calories and to reduce the size of portions, and extend product mixes to incorporate foods that encourage healthy lifestyles. This position could be construed as extremely ethical on the surface because they are acting for the wellbeing of a nation and its inhabitants, (their customers,) which could therefore proceed to become a major boost to PR and brand/corporate reputation. This emulates a virtuous position (Nieto, 2009) of using wealth for common good (Chryssides & Kaler, 1996a) and if, as a result, the brand reputation of Mars increases and their CSR is well received, the company may be endorsed by opinion-leaders such as governments and pressure groups (Haywood, 2005.) This effect can perpetuate across society whose citizens may decide to pay collectively for Mars’ goods and not turn away for ethical reasons, possibly rivalling the CSR of competitors such as Unilever (2013.) This hypothetical mass expenditure of disposable income arriving on Mars’ cash flow can then be used to increase R&D operations, which in turn can increase their health campaign through additional research. This can further increase the healthiness of the product range and as the cycle continues ad infinitum, the Mars brand may see a complete repositioning, taking it from a seemingly unhealthy company to a health-conscious corporate citizen. This would ultimately increase the happiness of the company and its major shareholders, as well as the consumers who are now healthier as a result of Mars’ actions, if seen from a utilitarian perspective. (Powell, 2012: Presentation; Chrissides & Kaler, 1996b.)

However, the utilitarian perspective does not satisfy deontological criteria and nor does it provide us with a conversion scale for the two types of happiness ‘measured’. The fact that Mars is a legal entity, a structure that is designed with the traditional sole intention of satisfying a bottom line financially (Beets, 2011,) the ethics applied to its position can cynically be perceived to be a mere PR exercise to generate brand awareness and increase survival chances or market dominance, with little regard for unconditional principal. Although contemporarily there is a triple bottom line –one of those being social considerations- the only one of these three lines that impacts survival of businesses perpetually is financial performance e.g. liquidity to prevent failure, hence the hesitation to adapt, (Henriques & Richardson, 2004.) Moreover, the responsibility deal was a voluntary option not enforced by law (Mercer, 2013,) which suggests that Mars’ commitment was possibly born of insidious motives and not due to a categorical imperative of moral upstanding (Kant, 1785,) due to the following question: Why has the company only recently drawn attention to the issue, when it is fresh in the minds of key opinion-leaders/-formers, after the policy was announced by Mars' regulators, the government? This suggests that Mars were already aware of this and chose to ignore it beforehand and let the public live in ignorance/apathy. This opinion is reiterated by economist Milton Freidman, who states that CSR is only ethical when done insincerely, precisely because it is used as method to increase profits, the real moral obligation that officers/directors have to shareholders (Bakan, 2005.) Suffice it to say, Mars' actions are akin to a child ceasing to conduct themselves disorderly, for fear of force enacted by a parental figure.

But Utilitarianism, however, may be seen as more positive from a practical standpoint because Mars possesses a catalogue of resources that will aid the nation’s problems. The trade-off of insincerity for accomplishing the objective may be the best way forward and to suggest that its position is unethical may be construed as counter-productive pedantry due to ‘higher-order’ priorities. The “…man dissatisfied is better than the pig satisfied” quote is testament to this: Mill, (1906: 260.) There is also the philosophical argument to contend with regarding CSR, since corporations as legal ‘people’ cannot think and feel like humans. So, to expect a duty-bound ethic on this topic when perceived through the lens of ‘Mars’, instead of individual humans is easily evaluated as impossible, since Mars is not human and therefore not a moral vessel (Achbar & Abbott, 2003a.)

This leaves us with a predicament where a compromise must be sought between the two sides of the argument, since today’s reigning opinion on CSR is that companies should strive to achieve it for the good of society (Warren, 2000,) despite the fact that over recent years, this attitude has fallen behind in wake of the recent financial crisis (IPSOS-MORI, 2012: Online.) This attitude of CSR-conscientiousness would be especially true if one were to accept the anthropomorphic nature of Mars, since real humans for the most part have changed in terms of a moral zeitgeist i.e. ‘spirit of the times’ (Dawkins, 2006,) resulting in a paradigm shift of morality and therefore, our corporate citizens should do the same since they are ultimately comprised of human, moral agents. They -like the rest of society- must abide by the same laws, unless of course the nature of their duty-bound role of profit making inhibits this effect, but why else would society allow companies to exist, if not to serve the interests of their societies? (Christian, 2012: Presentation.) There is a semi-popular notion that our relationship with corporations, is akin to Frankenstein’s monster overpowering its creator; could this be why companies struggle to maintain ethicality? (See Achbar & Abbott, 2003b, “Psychopath” analysis of corporate structure/’personality’.)

ETHICAL POSITION OF THE CRTICS & THE CASE AGAINST THE GOVERNMENT REPONSIBILITY DEAL:

The responsibility deal has come under criticism from certain groups and individuals such as Professor Simon Capewell, who accused Minister Lansley of “…gross dereliction of duty,” (Wright, 2012b: Online.) This criticism of the scheme is born from the potential PR opportunity that food companies have been given, which can be construed as a conflict of interest since companies are volunteering to do this, meaning that they can sign up and possibly do something negligible and still reap the same benefits. This can, in short, do nothing other than increase the market domination of the oligarchies within the food industry (Author Unknown, 2012.) A similar criticism is made by Professor Anna Gilmore, who also believes that there is a conflict of interest, since companies have to legally make returns for shareholders and would therefore not necessarily act in the interests of other stakeholder groups. (Hughes, 2012: Online.)

Both of these opinions link to deontological ethics, since the notion of Mars using the nations problems that it is –at least in part- responsible for and proceeding to rectify its wrongdoings whilst under public watch, purely to benefit from their trust and essentially use them as a means to an end (greater profit etc.,) would be considered unethical under Kantian tenants. Teleological ethics on the other hand, would consider policy/practice over principles as the ethically upstanding view, since good can still come of this situation- as previously mentioned (Fisher & Lovell, 2005.)   

Other critics of the responsibility deal include Gilmore et al. (2011,) who state that the food and alcohol industries have been given special pleading in cooperating with the government since other industries e.g. tobacco, are excluded from such activity by WHO. The article also states that tobacco’s lack of involvement with such schemes has seen a decline in the number of casualties etc., whereas the scenario is the opposite regarding food/alcohol, branding the problem an “…industrial epidemic: Online.”

The government responsibility deal can be seen as counter-productive or unethical, due to its inclusion of those who are in the wrong to begin with. Mars and its shareholders/directors etc. know what effects their products and services have on society, yet they continue to associate themselves with these ills because it is profitable. For government to enlist the help of those who have little/no genuine interest in solving health problems violates ethics of the duty of government, who do have the duty to look after the citizenry via the NHS. Yet they choose to delegate this responsibility back into the hands of those who caused the problem to begin with, who then realize that they can ‘sell the cure’ back to the citizens and ultimately be happier than the citizens whom they disingenuously ‘helped’. From this point it can perpetuate over several years, companies ‘apologizing’ and rectifying their wrongs to retain those whom they wronged. This helps save reputation and therefore business through these so-called ‘responsibility deals’.     

CONCLUSION:

In conclusion, the responsibility deal can be seen as both ethical and unethical depending on personal ethics and schools of thought. The main points to consider in this debate regard the model of principles v practice. The fact that Mars has effectively used customers as a means to an end i.e. not treated them as humans who have health problems, is seen by deontologists as unethical. However, the teleologically-inclined see the action of corporate involvement as the best way forward, due to the practicality of them doing right by their wrongs; possibly a form of justice.

However, there are other issues since the ethics argument is more than a two-way discussion, since it may not be government or Mars to blame for the problems of the nation. There are other schools of thought such as Objectivism. Rand would argue that personal responsibility (Bowie, 2001) of those with health problems would require that Mars and the government do nothing. Additionally, a study from Mintel, (2012) states that with Briton’s incomes reduced and food prices rising, citizens are eating less regardless, although cheaper food tends to be unhealthy.

In terms of personal opinion and plan of action to tackle the key issues of food marketing raised, the best solution seems to be to cut down on unhealthy numbers but without reducing portion sizes and increasing prices. This would be ethical since it not only gives consumers healthier diets, but also does not take advantage since the portions are still the same amount for the same price. This means that –providing consumers do their part- the population will be healthier overall and will therefore live longer, happier lives meaning their attitude towards food companies should not be tarnished, aiding profitability. This leads to positive acclaim of said companies and through this positive reception, the wider industry may also be able to increase its own opinion space in current affairs/government policy etc. and should it maintain its image of integrity and morality, a cycle of progress should ensue involving both government and industry working together to increase ethical consumption across society. The key point here is the lack of short-term profit-making and CSR that is deserved since prices are kept the same, or even possibly lowered so portions remain congruent with prices so profits remain the same. The main problem with this view is that, deontologically, it still looks out for the best interests of business since the emphasis is on the longer-term aspects of citizens living longer to consume more. The idea of forced lack of profit-making however, can eliminate the increased happiness of the industry in the short-term, instead remaining vis-à-vis with consumer happiness.

From the second perspective of Mars’ CMO, the ethical action would be to satisfy superiors by delivering a new system of reducing unhealthy aspects of foods and possibly engaging in philanthropic activities to alleviate as much damage as possible caused. Since the job is on the line, it would be better for one to retain the position of power and enact actual change and attempt to take Mars as high up the CSR Pyramid (Carroll, 1991,) as possible to become as much an ethical corporate citizen as Mars can be. There are other stakeholders, who also have equal rights to free speech, entitlements to profit etc. In short, the model of the corporation is here to stay and to even think that the logical position is to reject one that takes society forward on these issues, because it is not perfect, commits nirvana fallacy (Bennett, 2013: Online.) The real question surrounding this issue could be: Can corporations truly be ethical under tenants such as categorical imperatives, or does the pinnacle lie at egoism of fulfilling moral duties to further self-interest, because Mars is after all, an anthropomorphic legal structure.      

REFERENCES:

-      Author Unknown. (2012) ‘Health Secretary Andrew Lansley Criticised Over Government Obesity Policy’ Huffington Post. [Online] August 27th [accessed December 9th 2012]
-     Bakan, J. (2005) The Corporation: The Pathological Pursuit of Profit & Power p. 34 London: Constable & Robinson ltd.
-       Beets, S. (2011) ‘Critical Events in the Ethics of U. S. Corporation History’ Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 102 Issue 2 pp. 193-219 
-       Bennett, B. (2013) Nirvana Fallacy [Online] [accessed January 18th 2013] http://www.logicallyfallacious.com/index.php/logical-fallacies/135-nirvana-fallacy
-       Bowie, R. A. (2001) Ethical Studies p. 93 Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes
-       Carroll, A. B. (1991) ‘The Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility: Towards the Moral Management of Organisational Stakeholders’ Business Horizons Vol. 34 No. 4 pp. 39-48
-       Christian, J. (2012) Full Spoken-Word Statement: “[I believe] businesses exist to make society better otherwise, why would we allow them to exist?” 6/12/12 [14:00-15:00] LECTURE 10: The Triple Bottom Line (Lecture Hall: G.27)
-       Chryssides, G. & Kaler, J. (1996) Essentials of Business Ethics p. 32 Berkshire: McGraw-Hill
-       Ibid. p. 34
-       Dawkins, R. (2006) The God Delusion pp. 300-301 London: Bantam Press
-       Department of Health, (2012a.) About the Public Health Responsibility Deal [Online] [accessed September 30th 2012] http://responsibilitydeal.dh.gov.uk/about/
-       Department of Health, (2012b.) Our Partners [Online] [accessed September 30th 2012] http://responsibilitydeal.dh.gov.uk/our-partners/
-       Department of Health, (2012c.) Facts & Figures on Obesity [Online] [accessed January 14th 2012] http://www.dh.gov.uk/health/2012/04/obesityfacts/
-       Fisher, C. & Lovell, A. (2005) Business Ethics & Values p. 100 Essex: Pearson Education
-       Gilmore, A. B., Savell, E. & Collin, J. (2011) ‘Public Health, Corporations & the New Responsibility Deal: Promoting Partnerships with Vectors of Disease’ Journal of Public Health [Online] February 2nd  [accessed December 10th 2012] http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/content/33/1/2.full#ref-16
-       Haywood, R. (2005) ‘Corporate/Investor Relations: Build a Reputation that Becomes the Company’ In: Corporate Reputation, the Brand & the Bottom Line London: Kogan Page
-       Henriques, A. & Richardson, J. (2004) The Triple Bottom Line, Does it All Add Up? Assessing the Sustainability of Business & CSR pp. 5-8 Ipswich: Earthscan  
-       Hughes, D. (2012.) Can the Government’s ‘Responsibility Deal’ Work? BBC. [Online] [accessed December 10th 2012] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-12776161
-       IPSOS-MORI, (2012.) Whatever Happened to ‘Corporate Social Responsibility’? [Online] [accessed December 3rd 2012] http://www.ipsos-mori.com/newsevents/ca/1265/Whatever-happened-to-Corporate-Social-Responsibility.aspx
-       Kant, I (1785); translated by: Ellington, J. W. Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals 3rd Ed. p. 30 Hackett: Indiana
-       Mars Foods UK, (2012.) Delivery Plans from Partner: Mars UK- F2. Salt Reduction [Online] [accessed November 25th 2012] http://responsibilitydeal2.dh.gov.uk/render.php?r=805
-       Mars Global, (2012.) Brands: Chocolate [Online] [accessed November 27th 2012] http://www.mars.com/global/brands/chocolate.aspx
-       Mercer, C. (2013) INTERVIEW: Responsibility Deal Food Chair Dr Susan Jebb Just Food. [Online] [accessed January 25th 2013] http://www.just-food.com/interview/responsibility-deal-food-chair-dr-susan-jebb_id121884.aspx
-       Mill, J. S. (1906) Utilitarianism p. 260 Chicago: University of Chicago Press
-       Mintel. (2012) Dieting Trends: Executive Summary -UK November 2012 p. 2 London: Mintel Group
-       Nieto, D. V. (2009) ‘Corporate Social Responsibility as Part of Your Brand’ Manager: British Journal of Administrative Management Issue 68 pp. 28-29
-       Powell, M. (2012) LECTURE 8: Applying Ethical Principles Slide No. 11 [POWERPOINT] Manchester: MMU, distributed on: 15/11/12 Lecture Hall: G.27
-       Reynolds, J. (2012) ‘Tesco & Mars Sign Up to Latest Wave of Responsibility Deal’ Marketing Magazine. [Online] 15th November [accessed November 25th 2012] http://www.marketingmagazine.co.uk/news/1160107/Tesco-Mars-sign-latest-wave-Responsibility-Deal/ 
-       The Corporation. (2003) Directed by M. Achbar. & J. Abbott. [DVD] Canada: Zeitgeist Films
-       Ibid.
-       Unilever, (2013.) Sustainable Living [Online] [accessed January 25th 2013] http://www.unilever.com/sustainable-living/
-       Warren, R. C. (2000) Corporate Governance & Accountability p. viii Wirral: Liverpool Academic Press
-       Wright, O. (2012) ‘Lansley Has Caved in to Fast Food Industry, Says Former Advisor’ The Independent [Online] 27th August [accessed January 14th]
-       Ibid.


BIBLIOGRAPHY:

-       Albuquerque, D. (2011.) Business Ethics: Principles & Practice 3rd Ed. India: Oxford University Press
-       Companies Act 2006. (c.46) London: HMSO.
-       Edwards, T. (2000.) ‘Marketing, Advertising and the Construction of the Contemporary Consumer’ In: Contradictions of Consumption: Concepts, Practices & Politics in Consumer Society pp. 52-79, Philadelphia: Open University Press
-       Food Inc. (2008) [DVD] (Kenner, R.) USA: Magnolia Pictures
-       Haywood, R. (2005) ‘Public Affairs: Set the Agenda for Legislators & Opinion Leaders’ In: Corporate Reputation, the Brand & the Bottom Line London: Kogan Page 
-       Klein, N. (2000) No Logo 10th Anniversary Ed. Hammersmith: Haper-Collins
-       Lukas, B. A., Whitwell, G. J. & Heide, J. B. (2013) ‘Why Do Customers Get More Than They Need? How Organisational Culture Shapes Product Capability Decisions’ Journal of Marketing Vol. 77 No. 1 pp. 1-12
-       Pettet, B. (2005) Company Law 2nd Ed. Essex: Pearson Education
-       Sriramesh, K. & Vercic, D. (2003) The Global Public Relations Handbook New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
-       Wang, A. & Anderson, R. B. (2011) ‘A Multi-Staged Model of Consumer Responses to CSR Communications’ Journal of Corporate Citizenship Spring: Issue 41 pp. 51-68